Best Superhero Trilogy Thus Far

[Spider-Tim 075]

I know posting this question on THE SPIDER-MAN BOARDS is probably stupid.

Fresh and rotten are terms from http://www.rottentomatoes.com whitch collects all the reviews and sums them up. Below 60% is rotten on there.

And I recently looked into this again:

Batman(Tim Burton): Fresh with critics
Batman Returns: Fresh with critics
Batman Forever: Rotten

Superman: Fresh
Superman II:Fresh
Superman III:Rotten

X-Men: Fresh
X-Men 2: Fresh
X-Men 3: Rotten

Spider-Man: Fresh
Spider-Man 2: Fresh
Spider-Man 3: Fresh

And I don't agree with all this but I DO think that Spider-Man has atleast for the moment managed to generate the best trilogy. Now King-Kong and other Batman-Fans here: Don't hit me with THE NEW BATMAN WILL BE BETER. Cause it's batman's second attempt at making a 3-film-fresh movie. And for first times Spidey has done the best.

Anyone disagree?

[Spider-Z]

Spidey 3 not good as the rest. So I would give it a rotten.

[Spider-Tim 075]

Spidey 3 not good as the rest. So I would give it a rotten.

Ok then sure I'll give you that. But what (first) trilogy is the best. Spidey or another?

[socool83]

Spidey 3 not good as the rest. So I would give it a rotten.

why rotten
on the site fresh means it was just better than 60%

[Ock/Joker fan]

Spider-Man 3 is the rotten apple to me. And it shouldn't have been. All those other trilogy movies listed had changes in actors or directors or both.

Spidey maintained the same cast and director for Spider-Man 3, and it turned out ****.

Heres hoping Chris Nolan's Batman movies will break the curse.

[Spider-Tim 075]

Spider-Man 3 is the rotten apple to me. And it shouldn't have been. All those other trilogy movies listed had changes in actors or directors or both.

Spidey maintained the same cast and director for Spider-Man 3, and it turned out ****.

Heres hoping Chris Nolan's Batman movies will break the curse.

did you vote no? Out of interrest buddy don't worry. We're all hoping he breaks the curse. But as I said: This is Batmans second attempt. Spidey had his first. I do think the Spidey trilogy didn't go as wrong as Batman forever did for example

[Ock/Joker fan]

Yes, I voted no. Because X-Men 1 and 2, Batman and Batman Returns, Superman 1 and 2, are all good movies. Just like Spider-Man 1 and 2. It's just part 3 of these franchises that suck.

[F346]

I did'n't think X3 was that bad.

[Ock/Joker fan]

I did'n't think X3 was that bad.

They killed Cyclops after 2 minutes of screen time. Juggernaut was a retard. Rogue and Mystique got cured. The Phoenix had hardly any lines for the whole movie. Angel was pointless.

Magneto and Beast were the only good things about that movie, IMO.

[F346]

They killed Cyclops after 2 minutes of screen time. Juggernaut was a retard. Rogue and Mystique got cured. The Phoenix had hardly any lines for the whole movie. Angel was pointless.

Magneto and Beast were the only good things about that movie, IMO.

Oh, well, except that.

[dbzchuck]

They killed Cyclops after 2 minutes of screen time. Juggernaut was a retard. Rogue and Mystique got cured. The Phoenix had hardly any lines for the whole movie. Angel was pointless.

Magneto and Beast were the only good things about that movie, IMO.

Wow... I've never something so factual and so blunt at the same time. :congrats: Its very true, though!

[Sandman50407]

i say the spidey films aren't THE best trilogy. not saying the superman films are, even though i love superman III.

[F346]

then which one is it?

[Sandman50407]

none of them. i love certain, in the case of spidey films, movies like 1 and 3.

in the case of superman, i know everyone, :rolleyes:, hates III, but i love it.

in batman's case, love the first one and batman forever. batman begins was pretty cool and i do not like TDK so far. never have.

[F346]

yeah, I'm not that into batman either anymore as I was when I was younger.

[Sandman50407]

you know i find it ironic what with me being a huge superman fan, but, batman: TAS was the first cartoon i ever saw. the cartoons, for me, are what makes bats cool. not the movies.

[Ock/Joker fan]

BTAS is the best superhero cartoon ever.

Bar none.

[Sandman50407]

it was pretty awesome when i was a kid, 4 or 5 years old watching it. still is.

[F346]

you know i find it ironic what with me being a huge superman fan, but, batman: TAS was the first cartoon i ever saw. the cartoons, for me, are what makes bats cool. not the movies.

yup, same here.

[luke123]

Spider-man is clearly the best trilogy but just wait till the new batmans come through

[King-Kong]

Eh, it's hard to telll
I'll say it's between spidey trilogy and the original batman trilogy and xmen
hard to choose...seing it as their 3rd movies stunk

[calebyourmaster]

Spidey is the best Trilogy no doubt
Batman and X-Men in second

[venom16]

i've noticed that all threequels are the worst in the films' franchise

sm3... the worse spiderman (not my opinion... yours)

xmen3... bad

blade3... 2 was better

superman3...

batman forever...

[luke123]

i've noticed that all threequels are the worst in the films' franchise

sm3... the worse spiderman (not my opinion... yours)

xmen3... bad

blade3... 2 was better

superman3...

batman forever...


yeah its really hard to go three movies without screwing everything up

the only good third movies are
Return of the King
Return of the Jedi
Indiana Jones 3

thats all i can think of

[Spider-Tim 075]

Spider-man is clearly the best trilogy but just wait till the new batmans come through

till Batman 3 comes out then ... :D Aslong as they don't introduce Robin EVER it will be ok


But good to see you agree lol :D

[Spider-Tim 075]

yeah its really hard to go three movies without screwing everything up

the only good third movies are
Return of the King
Return of the Jedi
Indiana Jones 3

thats all i can think of

dispite that LOTR 3 isn't my fav I agree it didn't screw things up my friend. Love returns of the jedi to bits! And Indiana Jones wow 3's my fav actually

[Spider-Tim 075]

Eh, it's hard to telll
I'll say it's between spidey trilogy and the original batman trilogy and xmen
hard to choose...seing it as their 3rd movies stunk

I basicly agree. Those are the superhero movies (along with Supes I suppose) who managed to make 2 without trouble. And then go wrong. But like my friend Sandman said: I don't dislike Supes 3 actually, I prefer it to 2

[bmwdriver]

Hell Yea!

[Jick08]

I'd give a rotten for SM3.

but..between Batman trilogy, X-Men Trilogy and Spider-Man trilogy...
SM Trilogy was the best.

[Spider-Tim 075]

I'd give a rotten for SM3.

but..between Batman trilogy, X-Men Trilogy and Spider-Man trilogy...
SM Trilogy was the best.

I agree (but as a fan+seeing some good things about SM3 I would give it fresh)

[Spider-Tim 075]

Hell Yea!

indeed

no surprise

Best hero/character = Best movies

[Rodger-Dodger]

I did'n't think X3 was that bad.
me neither, but SM3 was definately better.
They killed Cyclops after 2 minutes of screen time. Juggernaut was a retard. Rogue and Mystique got cured. The Phoenix had hardly any lines for the whole movie. Angel was pointless.

Magneto and Beast were the only good things about that movie, IMO.

Cyclops is my favorite x man. I want a spinoff on him and Jean Grey. The xmen films only focus on wolverine. The wolverine spinoff won't be any different from the xmen films.

[raider34r]

Batman-Fans here: Don't hit me with THE NEW BATMAN WILL BE BETER. Cause it's batman's second attempt at making a 3-film-fresh movie. And for first times Spidey has done the best.

Anyone disagree?

IMO, if it wasnt for joel schumacher directing Batman Forever, and had Michael Returned for a 3rd movie and possibly Tim Burton, i think batman 3 would of been alot better and we would of had an actual, great Batman Trilogy

[web_head_33]

Yes, I voted no. Because X-Men 1 and 2, Batman and Batman Returns, Superman 1 and 2, are all good movies. Just like Spider-Man 1 and 2. It's just part 3 of these franchises that suck.

agreed for sure

[aliensuit1495]

spidey trilogy for sure
one bad movie (in you guy's opinion) doesn't ruin what the other 2 achieved

[web_head_33]

spidey trilogy for sure
one bad movie (in you guy's opinion) doesn't ruin what the other 2 achieved

i don't like them as much as i did before but they r better than the other superhero trilogys so far but i think the new batman trilogy will be 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0000000000000x better than the old one

[Jick08]

i don't like them as much as i did before but they r better than the other superhero trilogys so far but i think the new batman trilogy will be 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0000000000000x better than the old oneI hope Hulk and Iron-Man can build good trilogies too.

[web_head_33]

I hope Hulk and Iron-Man can build good trilogies too.

yup

[bmwdriver]

Cyclops is my favorite x man. I want a spinoff on him and Jean Grey. The xmen films only focus on wolverine. The wolverine spinoff won't be any different from the xmen films.

Cyclops is one of my favourite X-Mens too, but I don't want anymore SPinOffs!

[Spider-Tim 075]

spidey trilogy for sure
one bad movie (in you guy's opinion) doesn't ruin what the other 2 achieved

indeed. We should all remember to respect the originals witch are still IMO the best superhero movies and some of the best movies ever made

[Jick08]

Cyclops is one of my favourite X-Mens too, but I don't want anymore SPinOffs!
they said that there'll be a lot of spin-offs after Wolverine, but the big most will come direct to DVD.
the only characters that probably will get their own movies are Deadpool and Magneto.

[bmwdriver]

Deadpool should be cool (it's not even a SpinOff, right?), but Magneto isn't needed.

Wait?!? Even MORE Spin-Offs?!? I think I'm gonna be SICK!

[venom16]

they said that there'll be a lot of spin-offs after Wolverine, but the big most will come direct to DVD.
the only characters that probably will get their own movies are Deadpool and Magneto.

i knew magneto was gonna happen... but deadpool?

[bmwdriver]

I'd tell what Spin-Off I'd Preffer: a SILVER SURFER Spin-Off! It would be awesome to see Norrin Radd's Story on Screen, of course if done the right! ;)

[venom16]

I'd tell what Spin-Off I'd Preffer: a SILVER SURFER Spin-Off! It would be awesome to see Norrin Radd's Story on Screen, of course if done the right! ;)

it's gonna happen...

check wikipedia... fantastic four film series

[bmwdriver]

:eek:

The Next thing you know we'll be hearing about The Mr. Ditkovich Spin-Off! :D

[luke123]

I'd tell what Spin-Off I'd Preffer: a SILVER SURFER Spin-Off! It would be awesome to see Norrin Radd's Story on Screen, of course if done the right! ;)

i agree that would be sweet

[calebyourmaster]

IMO, if it wasnt for joel schumacher directing Batman Forever, and had Michael Returned for a 3rd movie and possibly Tim Burton, i think batman 3 would of been alot better and we would of had an actual, great Batman Trilogy

yeah...but it didnt...because people were furious about Batman Returns being so dark and were complaining to WB so they tried to tone down the script(Batman Forever ****) and Keaton said no....The rest is history

[Spider-Tim 075]

:eek:

The Next thing you know we'll be hearing about The Mr. Ditkovich Spin-Off!

I want a Mr. Ditkovich Spin-Off so badly!! It would be exstremely funny. I also want a "The Guy Who Said : Wooo, He Stole That Guys Pizza's Spin-Off" :p

[F346]

How about a JJJ spinoff.:D

[Spider-Tim 075]

How about a JJJ spinoff.:D

Spidey : The character with the most-unexpected spin-offs. Hmmm we might get an award for that. This could work :D

[raider34r]

yeah...but it didnt...because people were furious about Batman Returns being so dark and were complaining to WB so they tried to tone down the script(Batman Forever ****) and Keaton said no....The rest is history

becuz of the kids, Batman Returns was too scary for kids,for some, not me and the franchise went down hill becuz of the kid friendly more ****pier batman movies

i hope they dont screw things up with future Spiderman movies even though its already kid friendly

[F346]

Spidey : The character with the most-unexpected spin-offs. Hmmm we might get an award for that. This could work :D

lol.

[bmwdriver]

How about a JJJ spinoff.:D

Definately, why not? :spidey_thumbs:

[web shooters]

o yea, spidey is defently the best:D

[FIFTY...CENT]

i love spiderman 3 and 1 .....they were best triology films ever i have seen

[FIFTY...CENT]

i love spiderman 3

[Spider-Tim 075]

i love spiderman 3 and 1 .....they were best triology films ever i have seen

yeah indeed one of the best ever

[spider-jide]

No way is the spider-man series the best superhero trilogy. SM1 and 2 were meh and sm3 was a huge embarrassment.

Batman and batman returns are superior
superman and superman 2 are sperior
x-men and x-men 2 are superior.

Hell, all 3rd films upto now for comic book movies tend to suck but sm3 really took the cake with their embarrassing third entry.

However, with the way some properties are shaping up, it wont be long before we have a handful of great comic book trilogies and the Nolan Batman films looks set to be the first to achieve this, assuming Nolan and Bale do a third movie which is pretty much guranteed.